Best Carbon Steel Pan Reviews and Guide

Best Carbon Steel Pan Reviews: Are you looking for the best cookware for your kitchen? If yes, then you are here at the right place. You know cooking is often calculated as a home science category. There is no chance to deny that it does carry a huge measure of artistry.

Real artists in the kitchen just like sculptors and painters understand that the top way to makes a real art is to have the best units you can buy. But when it comes to cooking your favorite dish out in the kitchen it seems a quality cookware.

There are different types of cookware sets out on the market which is made from different materials. So it is quite challenging and confusing to choose the best one for your needs. Today we are going to discuss here carbon steel cookware and specifically the best carbon steel pan.

Carbon steel is consist of both carbon and iron as same as the cast iron. But if you are looking for a bit faster and lighter which is behaving to differences in temperature then buying the best carbon steel pan might be a more appealing option to you.

In this guide, we will discuss all the carbon steel pan and makes a list of top 5 best carbon steel pan and their reviews.

Recommended Top 5 Best Carbon Steel Pan for 2018

If you are a serious cook then you definitely have the best pans or pots. Having the best pan is important and must have a tool that helps you to cook a delicious food in the kitchen.

But if you are confusing which is the best carbon steel pan out on the market then here I will discuss some top models and their reviews. I hope it will definitely make your search easy for you:

1. DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan

best carbon steel pan

The DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan is the first choice in our top 5 best carbon steel pan review guide. It is one of the best-rated pans out on the market that has plenty of features. Let’s discuss these features are given below:

High quality

DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan is a high-quality unit in your kitchen. This carbon steel pan is ideal for searing or frying your most liked foods.

Superior cooking experience

DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan is an excellent cookware tool that provides you a superior cooking experience. It also provides you a long time cooking solution.

Easy to clean

One of the best features of this pan is that it does not stick while you are cooking. So you can easily clean this carbon steel pan.


DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan is thick enough which is an exception among others that make it best around the world. It is also quality equipment and tools for cooking as well.

Highlighted Features

  • Great carbon steel frying pan
  • Suitable for searing and frying foods
  • This pan does not stick while cooking
  • It is wonderfully seasoned pan
  • It lasts for years
  • Flatiron handle attached with rivets


  • It is suitable for oven to 250°f
  • You can wash it with hot water
  • Heats up faster than others
  • The handle stays cool
  • Great pan for the money


  • It needs 3-4 hours to cool
  • It is little difficult to season

Overall, the DeBuyer Carbon Steel Frying Pan is excellent which performs flawlessly. It works well, longer and nice cookware for any types of cooking. I would highly recommend this carbon steel pan but also suggest seasoning it properly.

2. Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet

best carbon steel pan

The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet another best selling and top rated cookware set on our review list. It seems to be the best value for carbon steel. It is best due to its top-rated features. Let’s discuss these features below:

Carbon steel

Lodge CRS12 features a 12 gauge carbon steel that heats up quickly. It maintains the very high and very low temperature. It is also factory seasoned including natural soybean oil.

Versatile cookware

The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet is highly effective versatile cookware tools in the kitchen. It is suitable for both professional and home use.


The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet is excellent in residential kitchens which perform well. So it is especially recommended for professional kitchens. It also works well in outdoor cooking functions as well.


The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet comes with high-density metal construction. It has an excellent heating feature that makes the heating process even faster than others. It also retains the heat for even cooking as well.


The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet features a handle which is heat conductive to both oven and stovetop. It has a comfortable grip for carrying this pan comfortably from the oven.

Multi-Functional Cookware

The Lodge CRS12 Carbon Steel Skillet is ideal for sautéing, searing, braising, simmering, roasting, frying and baking. It has a smooth surface which is safe to use with metal objects like forks, knives, and spatulas.

Highlighted Features

  • High heat for best searing and browning
  • 12 gauge carbon steel
  • Made in the USA
  • Pre-Seasoned carbon steel skillet
  • 3 steel rivets hold handle safely


  • Highly effective and versatile cookware set
  • A pre-seasoned carbon steel pan
  • A thickness of the cooking surface
  • It lasts for decades of cooking
  • Multifunctional cookware
  • Non-stick like cooking surface


  • Little expensive than a cast iron cookware set
  • Cooking surface is little rough

This Pre-Seasoned carbon steel skillet is perfect unit to cook for 2 people. I love this pan as it works great. I would recommend this cookware set. So let’s get this soon!

3. MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan

best carbon steel pan

The MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan is a great unit with a great size. It is very well built carbon steel fry pan for your cooking needs. The top-notch features of this fry pan make it best among others. Let’s see the overall features below:

Eco-friendly cookware

The MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan is one of the most eco-friendly cookware out on the market. It is 100% natural where 99% pure Iron.


The MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan is heavy duty carbon steel construction. It is protected against oxidation due to its Bee Wax Finish. It also comes with very good seasoning.

Better performance

The MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan features an excellent performance with its non-stick surface. This pan is ideal for Grilling, Browning, and Sealing. The more use the better performance it will offer to the chef.

Safe to use

The MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan is safe to use as there is no toxic chemical in their construction.

Highlighted Features

  • 100% natural carbon steel fry pan
  • Included 99% Pure Iron
  • Without PTFE or PFOA construction
  • Free from toxic chemical
  • Made in France
  • The product has 2 handles


  • Eco-friendly cookware around the world
  • Better performance of cooking
  • It has an authentic French design
  • Lighter than cast iron pan
  • Heavy and better performance
  • Heats quickly and evenly


  • It is little tough to clean
  • It is lighter but not too much light enough you want

If you are looking for a great pan for the money then you definitely go for the MINERAL B Round Carbon Steel Fry Pan. It is really the one that I am looking for in my kitchen.

4. Paderno Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Frying Pan

best carbon steel pan

The Paderno Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Frying Pan is an excellent cookware which works amazing. It is really a better choice for your kitchen. It will provide you an ultimate cooking experience. Let’s take a look at the top-notch features of this steel pan below:


The Paderno Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Frying Pan comes with a thick surface. This pan is ideal for conducting high temperatures. It features truly excellent heat conduction.


The Paderno Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Frying Pan comes with flat and riveted handle. This Carbon Steel Frying Pan looks and feels great. The handle of this pan is heat conductive to both oven and stovetop.

Excellent performance

The Paderno Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Frying Pan is excellent for frying and searing. You will enjoy a good cooking experience throughout this pan.


The Paderno Carbon Steel Frying Pan is Heavy Duty unit which is amazing if seasoned properly. You can use this fry pan for decades if you use it properly.

Highlighted Features

  • Heavy Duty Carbon Steel pan
  • 12.5 Inch Frying Pan
  • Excellent heat conduction
  • Flat and riveted handle
  • Ideal for searing


  • The handle is metal and oven safe
  • It is comfortable to use
  • Performs beautifully from stovetop to oven
  • The great quality carbon steel pan
  • It is heavier than a stainless steel pan


  • It is not as heavy as cast iron pan
  • Not dishwasher-safe

Overall, it is a high-quality pan at a reasonable price. It looks like a dream which heats and cools down comparatively quickly. I highly recommend this cookware pan.

5. Matfer Bourgeat 062005 Black Steel Round Frying Pan

best carbon steel pan

The Matfer Bourgeat 062005 Black Steel Round Frying Pan is extremely handy and beneficial cookware set out on the market. It serving taste over 25 years of around the foodservice industry. Let’s see the features that it offers below:


The Matfer Bourgeat 062005 is really an unbelievable Black Steel Round Frying Pan which is extremely strong. This Black Steel Round Frying Pan is made to last long.

Heat distribution

The Matfer Bourgeat 062005 Steel Round Frying Pan is an ideal unit that distributes heat quickly and evenly. So you can prepare your cooking quickly and properly.


The Matfer Bourgeat 062005 Steelpan comes with high quality and extra strong steel strip handle. It is really a heavy duty construction. It is seasoned with nonstick use which lasts for long.

Cleaning process

After your first use you need to place the pan under the hot running water for a while and by the cleaning brush, you can remove the remains of the pans.

Highlighted Features

  • Black Steel Round Frying Pan
  • It is ideal for all hob types
  • Weight: 4 lbs. 11 oz
  • Diameter 11 7/8″, Height 2 1/8″
  • Nonstick use and prolonged life
  • Extra strong steel strip handle
  • Wash with hot water
  • Dry and re-grease lightly


  • It is a heavy duty construction pan
  • It is extremely durable for long-lasting
  • This pan is oven safe
  • Distributes the heat quickly and evenly


  • It is not dishwasher safe
  • Difficult to remove the protective coating

Overall, in my thought, it is a great pan for the money. It is highly useful and extremely a very significant part of your kitchen tool.

What are Carbon Steel Pans?

A carbon steel pan is one of the most important cookware that you need in your kitchen. It is made from carbon steel and also consists of a small amount (1% or 2%) of carbon and an alloy of iron. Carbon steel is very same to cast iron. But using carbon steel pan is more beneficial than an iron cast pan.

Carbon steel pans can withstand high temperature. They are non-toxic and oven safe and there is no leaking of chemicals when overheated. They are also durable and can last for years if you can maintain it properly.

The best carbon steel pan comes with a smooth surface. It is relatively easy to seasoning. They are also thinner and lighter and safe to use spatulas, metal knives, and many other kitchen tools. They never retain off odors.

What is the best way to use Carbon Steel Pans?

  • Carbon steel pans are great to use for cooking in the oven. It is also great for outdoor grillers, as well as on the stovetop. They also work well on different heat sources.
  • The carbon steel pan is perfect for different cooking techniques. It seems to be the first choice for frying meats and vegetables quickly in a little hot fat. It is also suitable for roasting chicken and steaks as well.
  • You can mix up eggs and fish with proper seasoning in the carbon steel pan. You are completely free from worry as it would not stick. It is also perfect for baking cornbread or apple pies.
  • Carbon steel pan is not ideal for stewing or cooking with lots of water. You should also avoid cooking like acidic food, tomatoes, lemons and wine or vinegar because carbon steel is reactive.
  • Carbon steel pan heats up quickly. It is a great heat conductor which is faster than iron and slower than copper or aluminum. It also cools off quicker than cast iron.

What to consider before buying the best carbon steel pan?

There are plenty of carbon steel pans out on the market. So it is little confusing to buy the best one. Here are guides that will make your purchase safe enough. Let’s take a look at the features below:

Heat Conductivity

One of the most important things you need to consider that how fast your carbon steel pan conducts heat to food. You should keep considering to buy those that are fast while the others are slow. According to the style of your cooking, you should buy the unit that provides you perfect heat conductivity.


You should consider the budget of your cookware set. But if you want to get a quality pan then you need to pay a little more compared to the low-quality ones. But if you have a limited budget then so it is better to balance the quality and your budget.


Another important thing you need to consider the durability of the carbon steel cookware set. The carbon steel pan features a durable construction.

Carbon steel pans are also heavy duty cookware set that lasts longer. Also, consider that you pan has corrosion free or rust free features that help you to use this unit for long since.


You should consider a lot of care about your cookware sets especially when cleaning. When it comes to cleaning your cookware you should consider the comfort level. That is why you should buy a carbon steel pan that is easy and fast to clean.

Final Verdict

We come to the conclusion in our best carbon steel pan review guide. Having a carbon steel pan is extremely good for those who spend their time mostly in the kitchen. The best carbon steel pan is durable, high-quality and useful kitchen tools that you cannot deny while cooking.

There is no doubt that it provides you a good service. So it becomes the best choice for many professional chefs in kitchens or restaurant around the world as well.  You can use this necessary cookware tools in different heat sources.

I hope after reading this article you will get all the information about carbon steel pans and finding the best one among our top 5 selections. These pans can be extremely powerful if you seasoning them properly. So let’s enjoy a delicious and breathtaking dish with this steel pan.

Do you like this article? If so, leave a comment below and let us know what you consider. Never wait to click inform and share others about best carbon steel pan. Thanks for staying with us ‘til the end of this guide!


Related Posts

7 thoughts on “Best Carbon Steel Pan Reviews and Guide

  1. Thanks for sharing nice article. People will get important information from your site. Besides cooking item we can storage small item in a small storage cabinet. Then we can arrange the cookers item easily. There are many kinds of small storage cabinet for kitchen are available in the market. You can see guidelines more to make attractive your kitchen.

  2. I have noticed you don’t monetize your website, don’t waste your traffic, you can earn extra cash every month because you’ve got high quality content.
    If you want to know how to make extra money, search for: Mertiso’s tips best adsense

  3. Fantastic goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and
    you are just too wonderful. I actually like what you have acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way in which you say it.
    You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep
    it smart. I can’t wait to read far more from you.
    This is actually a terrific web site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read also x